writing essentials: genre-based writing instruction
Part 3B Secret Site
PERSUADE & ARGUE
Links to Assignments in Writable
Elementary Course Assignments
Middle School Course Assignments
High School Course Assignments
Follow the what and why
PRIMARY & ELL | Expect multiple reasons to support each opinion.
Identify the two essential parts—the what and why.
Generate whole-class lists of reasons to support different opinions.
Transition from interactive writing to independent writing.
UPPER GRADES | Clarify the relationship among claims, reasons, & evidence.
Return to the table analogy to add the overall claim—the table cloth.
Generate single paragraph persuasives, before expecting multiple reasons.
Collect facts to infer reasons.
Connect the Reading Voice and Thinking Voice to generate arguments based on texts.
“Vulgar Language” resources
PROMPT | Argue whether the use of vulgar language is a big deal or no biggie.
“School Uniform” resources
PROMPT | Write a persuasive as to why schools should have uniforms.
PROMPT | Persuade the viewer to purchase a ShamWow.
“Christopher Columbus” resources
PROMPT | Argue whether Christopher Columbus should/should not be celebrated with a national holiday.
Video of MS social studies class inferring reasons.
“Genetic Engineering” resources
PROMPT | Argue whether genetic engineering should/should not be legal.
Cut apart the list of pro and con details collected from several articles. Group them to infer reasons. (Original passages are not available.)
View the original whole-class mini-lesson and follow-up small-group activity executed in a MS science class.
Order reasons intentionally
Save the best for last.
Present reasons to maximize reader impact.
Convert one-sided persuasives into two-sided arguments.
Transition between claims and counterarguments.
Move beyond a summary of reasons.
Dry-erase puzzle pieces demonstrate how different types of information can comprise argumentative conclusions.
Clinch it with a clever statement.
Download student writing samples with strong beginnings and endings.
- The Day Dreamers (Argumentative Research)